The First Lady of Mental Health: A 50-year journey
By Lei Ellingson
Senior Associate Director, Public Policy
With 200 buildings and spanning 2,000 acres, Central State Hospital in Georgia was one of the largest-ever mental hospitals in the world.
Now, its old prison, doctors’ houses and even a pecan grove sit abandoned, surrounded by 25,000 unmarked graves.
But in the 1970s, the hospital was still open. And notorious for mistreating patients.
While she campaigned for her husband Jimmy Carter to be Governor of Georgia, former First Lady Rosalynn Carter was approached almost daily by distressed family members with loved ones there.
Just before sunrise one morning, Mrs. Carter stood at the entrance to a cotton mill in Atlanta, waiting for people to get off of work, she recalled in her 2010 book, “Within Our Reach.”
She saw an older woman emerge alone.
The woman said she had a daughter who lived with a mental illness and that she and her husband struggled to make ends meet and care for their child.
“I’d been worrying about those in institutions and their families, but how many others were struggling to care for a loved one at home, without access to any professionals at all?” recounted Mrs. Carter in her book. “The scope of the problem overwhelmed me.”
This life-changing moment in 1970 set Mrs. Carter on a course that would consume her work for 50 years – advocating on behalf of people who have mental illnesses and substance use issues, and their families.
Taking the fight for mental health from Georgia to the White House
Soon after Jimmy Carter won the state election, the Governor’s Commission to Improve Services for Mentally and Emotionally Handicapped Georgians was created.
Mrs. Carter worked closely with commission members and on October 29, 1971, the commission issued its final report, “A Mental Health Improvement Plan for Georgia.”
Because of this seminal date, The Carter Center is honoring Mrs. Carter’s 50 years of advocacy on mental health issues during 2020 and 2021.
[Learn more about The Carter Center’s Mental Health Program on cartercenter.org.]
In the ensuing five decades, Mrs. Carter has accomplished much. And borne witness to devastating events.
Through the Carter Center’s Mental Health Program, she hosted an annual national symposium on mental health policy from 1985 to 2016.
The event launched three Surgeon General reports on mental health, including one on the mental health of children, and another addressing gender, race and ethnicity.
It also provided an opportunity to address the mental health effects of mass tragedies like Hurricane Katrina and the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001.
The greatest obstacles to treatment
From her time working on the first-ever President’s Commission on Mental Health while in the White House, Mrs. Carter has gathered colleagues and allies to promote parity for insurance coverage for mental health and substance use conditions.
When a health insurance plan has parity, it means behavioral health conditions are treated in the same way as other medical conditions.
A lack of parity means that many people, including children, are unable to afford behavioral health treatment.
Mrs. Carter and former First Lady Betty Ford testified before Congress in 1994 on this issue and Mrs. Carter testified again with David Wellstone, son of the late Senator Paul Wellstone, ensuring the passage of the Pete Domenici and Paul Wellstone Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act of 2008.
While Mrs. Carter advocated for mental health support and treatment, she concluded that one of the greatest obstacles to people seeking treatment and receiving the services they need is the stigma and discrimination tied to mental health and substance use conditions.
In fact, the topic for the very first symposium she held, with the assistance of the Emory University Department of Psychiatry, was stigma.
In April 1997, The Carter Center established the Rosalynn Carter Fellowships for Mental Health Journalism, the flagship program of the organization to combat stigma here and abroad.
Since then, the fellowships have awarded more than 225 journalists in the United States and abroad who have produced mental health projects in the media that more accurately and effectively report on mental health and substance use.
Mental health advocacy beyond the White House
After leaving the White House, President and Mrs. Carter returned to Georgia and have lived in the same home in Plains since 1961.
Mrs. Carter continues to advocate for mental health in her home state. In 1995, she began hosting an annual one-day meeting on mental health policy issues facing Georgia, known as the Rosalynn Carter Georgia Mental Health Forum.
Since 2008, Mrs. Carter and the Mental Health Program ramped up activities in Georgia.
After a series of articles in the Atlanta Journal-Constitution exposing the terrible conditions in the state’s psychiatric hospitals, the Mental Health Program began a two-pronged approach to improving the state’s public mental health system.
Firstly, the program gathered the state’s mental health advocacy organizations and considered suing the state with the Judge David L. Bazelon Center for Mental Health Law.
In the interim, the U.S. Department of Justice launched an investigation into the state hospitals that resulted in two settlement agreements between the state and the DOJ, the first in 2008 and the second in 2010.
The Carter Center and the group of advocates were named Amici curiae by the federal judge overseeing the settlement agreements.
During a very tense period during the talks, Mrs. Carter walked in and spoke to all of them.
“Mrs. Carter definitely turned the tide of how things were going that day,” said then-Bazelon Center attorney Alison Barkoff.
Barkoff added: “She assured us that she had every confidence that eventually we would be able to come to consensus because everyone had the same ultimate goal – to improve the lives of Georgians who have serious mental illnesses by transforming the public mental health system from one that was hospital-based to one that is community-based.”
Since 2010, the only regular public update on the state’s progress toward meeting the conditions of the settlement agreement has been provided at the annual Rosalynn Carter Georgia Mental Health Forum.
Secondly, The Carter Center’s Mental Health Program worked with the J.B. Fuqua Foundation to develop a document outlining the essential component of an effective community-based public mental health system, “Building a Vision for Community Services for Children, Adolescents, and Adults with Behavioral Health Disorders in Georgia.”
The Mental Health Program’s activities in Georgia have grown to promoting school-based behavioral health, improving the treatment services for and ensuring the rights of older adults who have mental illnesses and getting Georgia to enforce the parity laws for insurance coverage of behavioral health conditions.
Mental health is a global issue
Mrs. Carter also has long been the leading voice around the world for mental health issues.
She and President Carter traveled to Geneva in May 2004 for the annual World Health Assembly.
In his address to the Assembly, President Carter stressed that despite the availability of treatment for mental health conditions, too many people simply have no access.
Mrs. Carter reinforced this message during a technical briefing on Mental Health and Substance Abuse that included several countries.
In cooperation with the World Federation for Mental Health, Mrs. Carter formed the Committee of International Women Leaders for Mental Health, which included royalty, as well as sitting heads of state and first ladies.
They held two meetings, the first in 1996 with 17 members from the Americas and their Ministers of Health at the Pan-American Health Organization in Washington, D.C.
The second meeting was held in 1997 with 17 European members and their Ministers of Health in Helsinki, Finland. By 1999, the Committee had 36 members.
“One important event that grew out of these two meetings was the Inaugural World Conference on the Promotion of Mental Health and the Prevention of Mental and Behavioral Disorders,” said John Gates, former director of The Carter Center’s Mental Health Program and current member of the Mental Health Task Force.
“This was held at The Carter Center in 2002 and sponsored by the WFMH and the Clifford Beers Foundation. Over twenty countries were represented,” Gates recalled.
In 2010, at the request of the Liberian Ministry of Health, The Carter Center Mental Health Program expanded its global footprint to include Liberia.
The program began by training nurses, physician assistants and midwives in treating mental health and substance use conditions.
It also helped the country develop a modern national law addressing mental health and a national mental health plan for Liberia’s Ministry of Health.
The Carter Center provided the underpinnings for the development of a civil society advocacy organization run by and for Liberians who live with mental health and substance use conditions.
“I want people to know what I know – that today because of research and our knowledge of the brain, mental illnesses can be diagnosed and treated effectively, and the majority of those with these illnesses can recover and lead fulfilling lives…going to school, working, raising a family, and being productive citizens in their communities,” Mrs. Carter said.